AJ has a 3,500-person waiting list to try his pizza, and he makes every single one of them in a shared two-bedroom apartment in Ocean Beach, San Diego. That kind of demand would feel absurd anywhere. In a home kitchen with roommates, a girlfriend, and a single oven capped at 550 degrees, it borders on the surreal. But one afternoon in that apartment, watching dough hit the peel and customers sprint to the checkout button on their phones, the buzz stopped feeling like a social media story and started feeling like a genuinely earned thing.
A three-day dough, one oven, and a roommate who takes allergy meds
AJ grew up on the East Coast, moved to San Diego, and could not find the pizza he wanted. So he taught himself, largely through online tutorials, developing what he describes as his take on New York style mixed with a little Connecticut New Haven influence. The dough alone is a three-day process: yeast, ice water, honey, flour, salt, and olive oil blended together and fermented slowly. The sauce is a tomato and seasoning build that requires a focused palate to balance. The cheese blend has to hit an exact ratio of flavor and moisture. And then there is the oven itself, a standard apartment unit that tops out at 550 degrees and can only handle one pizza every 30 minutes, which means a full pop-up day runs 10 hours straight for a maximum of 20 pies.
His girlfriend Jessie has taken on an informal co-manager role. One of his roommates, when asked what it is like living with a pizza man, delivered the line flatly: ‘I have to take special meds because I’m actually allergic to pizza.’ The waiting list grew after a friend named Min posted about AJ’s pizza online and, as AJ put it, ‘it went pretty crazy.’ Orders move through an app called Hotplate. Pop-ups are announced every Saturday for the following week. When slots open, the race to checkout is real: three time slots opened during the afternoon, and they sold out in under a minute. AJ has only been selling to the public for about two months.
North County, a fellow dough obsessive, and what pressure does to a pie
Before the pop-up, AJ made a stop in North County to visit Sam, who goes by The Dough Guy and runs his own at-home pizza operation out of a similarly ordinary kitchen. Sam built his following partly by pursuing and eventually landing a review from Dave Portnoy, who said of Sam’s pizza: ‘You have absolutely no idea that it was made the way he made it.’ That attention allowed Sam to launch his own line of pizza steels. Unlike AJ, Sam does not sell pies. His angle, as he explained while dusting his countertop and pressing out a four-day fermented dough ball, is teaching people to make great pizza themselves: ‘Simplify it as much as possible to get you like 90% of the way there. Anybody can make a great pizza.’
Sam made two pies that afternoon. A plain cheese went first. After tasting it, AJ paused and admitted, ‘I’m not going to lie, that’s like better than my normal pizza.’ Sam did not argue. The second pie was a red onion, cilantro, rotisserie chicken, and bacon build finished with swirls of barbecue sauce and ranch. The verdict on the bottom crust: ‘tremendous.’ The fermentation, per AJ, was ‘on point again, got all the little micro blisters, good gluten structure, good balance of flavors.’
The pizza lottery, in real time
Back in Ocean Beach with the pop-up an hour away, AJ walked through the mechanics. Three pre-made options: cheese, pepperoni, and the PBR, which is pepperoni, basil, and fresh whipped ricotta finished with hot honey. One pizza per order. Twenty orders on a full day. For this afternoon, just three slots, gone in seconds.
The first customer, Isabella, had messaged AJ in November of the previous year before he was even selling pizzas. Her first bite: ‘That’s the most perfect sauce.’ She and her friend headed straight for the beach. The second customer, Daniel, arrived late because he had confused the day. AJ, who coordinates every order with real-time tracking updates through Hotplate, set the pizza aside and sent it out with a roommate rather than deliver it himself, which he said he disliked. Daniel later texted back: ‘Wow, this is the best pizza I’ve ever had. Keep doing what you’re doing, man. 100% worth the wait.’ The third customer, Brittany, lives down the street and had been waiting months. She had her husband and kids in the car and was told, firmly, not to wait before eating it.
The final pie of the day, the PBR made for the visiting journalist, landed like a confirmation of everything the list suggests. The cup-and-curl pepperoni, the fresh ricotta dolloped across the top, the hot honey, the crunch on the underside. AJ, asked if he was happy with himself, said simply: ‘Mhm.’
One pizza, per order, per pop-up
Brittany’s box sat on the passenger seat of her car for approximately thirty seconds before she drove away.
Back inside, AJ already had the next dough ball resting on the peel. The oven was still cranking. The Hotplate app had gone quiet. Twenty pizzas maximum, one at a time, out of a shared apartment in Ocean Beach, and a list of 3,500 people who are still waiting for their turn.
Wake up to Only Happy News!
